Ba-bye blissful bubble of peace and privilege! Hellooo police brutality...
This photo is not mine, I found it online at Portland's Independent Media Center when I investigated today. (Thank god for independent media, btw. We must preserve and protect at all cost.)
Anyway, I love a good protest almost as much as I hate police brutality. But they lost me with the hyperbole, and then sealed the deal by breaking windows at the local community college. C'mon, people - seriously? (Yeah, I'm talking to you, hippie-gangstas. When Malcolm said "by any means necessary," he didn't mean a bunch of white kids in black hoods walking the streets at night causing destruction to schools and businesses on MLK Blvd. In some places, I think they call that harassment and vandalism.)
Context is everything, isn't it? I had just finished watching the first season of The Wire, so I was feeling sympathetic to the police. If I had just watched Do the Right Thing, I might have felt differently. But then today I found the video of Oscar Grant's shooting by Oakland, California police (the reason for this protest). Yeah, pretty obvious abuse of power. Completely intolerable and protest-worthy. Not at all okay.
I craned my neck to spy a group of protesters marching toward Martin Luther King Jr. Blvd., just a couple blocks from here. No, I didn't put down my cocktail and join them. But I did get a quick look at the banner they were carrying:
This photo is not mine, I found it online at Portland's Independent Media Center when I investigated today. (Thank god for independent media, btw. We must preserve and protect at all cost.)
Anyway, I love a good protest almost as much as I hate police brutality. But they lost me with the hyperbole, and then sealed the deal by breaking windows at the local community college. C'mon, people - seriously? (Yeah, I'm talking to you, hippie-gangstas. When Malcolm said "by any means necessary," he didn't mean a bunch of white kids in black hoods walking the streets at night causing destruction to schools and businesses on MLK Blvd. In some places, I think they call that harassment and vandalism.)
Context is everything, isn't it? I had just finished watching the first season of The Wire, so I was feeling sympathetic to the police. If I had just watched Do the Right Thing, I might have felt differently. But then today I found the video of Oscar Grant's shooting by Oakland, California police (the reason for this protest). Yeah, pretty obvious abuse of power. Completely intolerable and protest-worthy. Not at all okay.
Sigh. Still thinking about the whole idea of "by any means necessary," I went back to read more about what Malcolm said.
"It doesn't mean that I advocate violence, but at the same time, I am not against using violence in self-defense. I don't call it violence when it's self-defense. I call it intelligence."
Smart man. I wonder what he would have made of these protesters? Well, I know what he might have said pre-pilgrimage, but he got a bit softer after returning from Mecca, didn't he? No more sweeping indictments of white people. All peace and brotherly love. So maybe this:
"Early in life I had learned that if you want something, you had better make some noise."Noise I can agree with. Turn the volume up, up, UP, I say. Raise your voice. And you know what this means....I just gotta post the best movie scene ever of all time. I know you've seen it a million trillion times, but it really never gets old. In fact, I think it should be what we recite instead of the Pledge of Allegiance. Seriously, imagine millions of darling little schoolchildren across the land exclaiming in unison each morning:
"I'm a human being, god damn it! My life has value!"Oh, what a wonderful world that would be. Enjoy:
Hey Claire, you might like this blog post by a former classmate of Scout's: http://paramecw.wordpress.com/2010/07/08/what-justice-oscar-grant-johannes-mehserle/#comments
ReplyDelete(She has a nice follow-up post too.) I'm pretty heartsick about the whole thing.
Beautiful post, Nora...thanks so much for sharing! Oh my goodness, I could rant forever about the Prisonal Industrial Complex and, as your friend called it, our "acute case of life-devaluation." We do some awfully stupid things in the name of justice and freedom. If we don't truly value ourselves and our fellow men, then, well...I think Janis Joplin sang it best: "Freedom is just another word for nothing left to lose."
ReplyDelete